Toronto Italia finished in second place in the 1986 NSL final league standings four points behind Toronto Blizzard. In the 1986 NSL Playoff final they defeated Toronto Blizzard 1-0.
The 1948 Carsteel team won the Dominion Championship and the Lord Atholstan Trophy.
Toronto Italia won the 1996 NSL Championship.
In the 1929 season the Montreal Canadian National Railway soccer eleven won the Dominion Championship, the National League championship, the Charity Cup and the championship of the Eastern Section of the National Soccer League.
Serbian White Eagles finished the 1973 as National Soccer League runners ups.
Toronto Croatia won the 1970 National Soccer League championship.