Seasons
Champions
| Season | League Champions | Playoff Champions |
| 1961 | Toronto City | Montreal Cantalia |
| 1962 | Toronto Roma | Toronto Italia |
| 1963 | Toronto Italia | Toronto Italia |
| 1964 | Toronto City | Toronto City |
| 1965 | Montreal Italica | Toronto Italia |
| 1966 | Toronto Italia-Falcons | Toronto Inter-Roma |
Record goalscorer (incomplete)
| Player | Goals |
| Carlos Metidieri | |
| Jorge Piotti | |
Records
Longest unbeaten run (per season)
21 games – Toronto Italia 1963
Most consecutive wins in a season
13 – Toronto Italia 1966
Record victory
Toronto City 10, Montreal Italia 1 May 31, 1964
Most goals in a game
4 – Ted Purdon – Toronto City vs Montreal Italia May 31, 1964
4 –
4 –
Fastest goal
19 seconds – Johnny Haynes (Toronto City) June 28, 1961