Hamilton City were members of the National Soccer League from 1927 to the end of the 1940 season.
1924 Inter-City League
Under the leadership of president Sam Farrant they were members of the Inter-City League in the 1924 season.
1925
1926
1927 – National Soccer League
Joined the National Soccer League.
1928
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1929
Annual meeting held in January 1929.
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1930
Losing finalists in the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1931
Losing finalists in the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1932
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1933
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1934
1935
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1936
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1937
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1938 – Hamilton Herald Cup winners
Won the Hamilton Herald Cup.
Losing finalists in the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1939 – Ontario Cup & Hamilton Spectator Cup Winners
Won the Ontario Cup.
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
Won the Herald Cup.
Won the Brigden Cup.
1940
Won the Hamilton Spectator Cup.
1941
Won Halliwell Cup.
1942
Discontinued as an organization due to World War II.
National Soccer League 