| Season | League |
| 1981 | National Soccer League |
| 1982 | National Soccer League |
| 1983 | Canadian Professional Soccer League |
| 1983 | National Soccer League |
| 1984 | Did not operate |
| 1985 | Did not operate |
| 1986 | Ontario Inter-City Soccer League |
| 1987 | Canadian Soccer League |
| 1988 | Canadian Soccer League |
| 1989 | Canadian Soccer League |
| 1990 | Canadian Soccer League |
| 1991 | Canadian Soccer League |
| 1992 | Did not operate |
Hamilton Steelers
