Hakoah Sport Club was formed in Toronto in 1963. The club joined the National Soccer League before the start of the 1963 season. The club reached the playoff finals but lost to Toronto Ukraina.
After the season Hakoah dropped out from the NSL and tried to join the Eastern Canada Professional Soccer League. Instead they ended up playing the 1964 season in the Ontario Soccer League.
Hakoah rejoined the National Soccer League in 1965. The club won the NSL playoff finals.
The club left the NSL after the 1965.