| Competition: | 1961 Eastern Canada Professional Soccer League |
| Date: | 18 June 1961 |
| Stadium: | Civic Stadium, Hamilton |
| Attendance: | 4,500 |
| Referee: | Alex Weir |
Goalscorers
| Hamilton Steelers 3 | Toronto Italia 3 |
| 09:00 Peter Smethurst | 06:00 Fred Bundschoks |
| 23:00 Peter Smethurst | 80:00 Bruno Bertolin |
| 49:00 Peter Smethurst | 82:00 Antonio Sistini |
Line-ups
| Hamilton Steelers | Pos | Toronto Italia |
| Volker Bauerle | GK | Gianni Di Davide |
| Dave Hartwell | RB | Pizzutti |
| Fillingham | LB | Sistini |
| Dal Pos | RJ | Schiabel |
| Baxter | CH | Kelly |
| Smith | LH | Lazzari |
| Joe Gabellini | OR | Bruno Bertolin |
| Bestenreiner | IR | Betella |
| Smethurst | CF | Bundschoks |
| Cannavacciuolo | IL | Chauvano |
| Shaw | OL | Tonani |
| McKay | Sub | Romanin |
| Furlanetto | Sub | Papais |
| Vickers | Sub | Piccioli |