| League: | 1959 National Soccer League |
| Date: | 16 July 1959 |
| Stadium: | Civic Stadium, Hamilton, Ontario |
| Attendance: | 2,500 |
| Referee: | |
| Linesmen: |
Goalscorers
| Hamilton Italo-Canadians 1 | Toronto Italia 2 |
Line-ups
| Hamilton Italo-Canadians | Pos | Toronto Italia |
| Vic Marchetti | 1 | Silvio Gaspari |
| Segato | 2 | Pizzutti |
| Jim McKay | 3 | Dan Guerra |
| Tenaglia | 4 | Fornero |
| Smith | 5 | Papais |
| Andy Furlanetto | 6 | Beppi Schiabel |
| Joe Gabellini | 7 | Bertolini |
| Ernie Stanfield | 8 | Cuccinelli |
| Jack Allister | 9 | Birba |
| Travaglini | 10 | Zanarini |
| Bedin | 11 | Emil Erbach |
| B McKay | 12 | |
| Occhiut | 13 | |
| Ciani | 14 | |
| Coach |