The British Consols Trophy was donated by the W. C. MacDonald Company in 1925. The first winners were Ulster United. Winning the British Consols Trophy was symbolic of being Toronto & District champions.

Winners

1925 Ulster United
1926 Willys Overland
1927 Ulster United
1928 Ulster United
1929 Ulster United
1930 Ulster United
1931 Ulster United
1932 Toronto Scottish
1933 Toronto Scottish
1934 Toronto Scottish
1935 British Consols
1936 Toronto Scottish
1937 Ulster United
1938 Ulster United
1939 Toronto Scottish
1940 Toronto Scottish

British Consols Trophy Finals

1925

Ulster United won

1926

April 23, 1927 Willys Overland 0, Craigavon 0

May 23, 1927 Willys Overland 3, Craigavon 1

Willys-Overland won

1927

December 3, 1927 Toronto Scottish 2, Ulster United 7

December 10, 1927 Ulster United 2, Toronto Scottish 1

Ulster United won series in two straight games

1928

November ??, 1928 Ulster United 3, Toronto Scottish 1

November 11, 1928 Ulster United 5, Toronto Scottish 0

Ulster United won two-game total-goal series 8-1

1929

Ulster United won series

1930

Ulster United won series

1931

Ulster United won series

1932

Toronto Scottish won series

1933

Toronto Scottish won series

1934

September 1, 1934 Corinthians 2, Toronto Scottish 1

September 8, 1934 Toronto Scottish 5, Corinthians 0

Toronto Scottish won series

1935

November 2, 1935 British Consols 4, Toronto Scottish 1

November ??, 1935 British Consols vs Toronto Scottish

British Consols won two-game series

1936

October ??, 1936 Toronto Scottish 2, Maple Leafs 0

October 24, 1936 Toronto Scottish 1, Maple Leafs 2

Toronto Scottish won two-game total-goals series 3-2

1937

September 18, 1937 Toronto Scottish 2, Ulster United 1

September 20, 1937 Ulster United 6, Toronto Scottish 0

Ulster United won two-game total-goal series 7-2

1938

October 8, 1938 Ulster United 3, Toronto Scottish 2

October 10, 1938 Ulster United 2, Toronto Scottish 3

October 15, 1938 Ulster United 2, Toronto Scottish 1

Ulster United won the three-game series

1939

Toronto Scottish won series

1940

August 31, 1940 England United 3, Toronto Scottish 2

September 3, 1940 Toronto Scottish 5, England United 2

Toronto Scottish won two-game total-goals series 7-5

Copyright @ thecnsl.com 2020